Skip Navigation Links
3 bed
2 bath
1,938 sfsquare feet
51 & 58 Peases Point Way, Chilmark, 02535

51 & 58 Peases Point Way, Chilmark MA 02535

A stunning portal into the most exquisite and unspoilt pond-front landscapes on Martha's Vineyard. The 180-degree view encompasses the fishing village of Menemsha, the long and protected Lobsterville dunes, and the backdrop of Vineyard Sound and the Elizabeth Islands. The irreplaceable water's edge location provides an intimate view of wildlife, fishing flats and memorable sunsets. Behind the house is the only fresh-water pond contiguous to the tidal Menemsha Pond; an avian magnet.
A one-half interest in adjacent 9.79-acres conservation meadows, shared with two neighbors, provides 1,800 feet of Menemsha Pond shoreline; swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding, shellfishing and shallow-water striped-bass fishing.
The 1,990-square-foot modernist house was designed in 1961 by a Prix-de-Rome winning student of Walter Gropius and is constructed entirely of old-growth, four-inch-thick, Western Red Cedar and has been lovingly restored to original condition. The upper floor 18' cathedral-ceiling, post-and-beam design has stunning water views from each room, including the en-suite bath. Oversized fireplace, in-kitchen grill with its own flue, Gaggeneau applicances and Corian showers.

The lower floor also has a fireplace and antique brick floors. Recently-installed central air and heat. Because of the sensitive location, house cannot be expanded and it is also subject to architectural covenants.
Listing Courtesy of Wallace & Co. Sotheby's International Realty
Request Information

Shakti Reynolds

  • This site is protected by reCAPTCHA see our Privacy Policy



  • Mls Id
  • Bedrooms
  • Full Baths
  • Appliances
    Stove: Y, Washer: Y
  • Water Source
  • Flooring
  • Foundation
  • Year Built
  • Exterior Features
    Water Views, Deck, Community Tennis Court, Beach Access - Private, Beach Access - Deeded, Covenants, Garden, Patio
  • Parking Features
  • Sewer
    Septic Tank
  • Heating
  • Utilities
  • Lot Features
  • Frontage
  • View
    Pond, D/Snd
  • Interior Features
    AC,OSh, Floor 1: Antique brick foyer opens to sitting room with water views. Two bedrooms, one full bath, stand alone shower. Large laundry room and utility area., Floor 2: Large living room extends the full width of the house and oversize windows frame exceptional water views. Well designed kitchen with dining. Master bedroom with en-suite bath.
  • Furnished
  • Zoning
  • Listing Updated
    Saturday, December 10, 2022, 12:03 AM
  • I am interested in the following
  • This site is protected by reCAPTCHA see our Privacy Policy
HomepageWallace & Co. Sotheby's International Realty - Martha's Vineyard Real Estate

P.O. Box 2005
One North Water Street
Edgartown, MA 02539

Edgartown Office: 508.627.3313
Chilmark Office: 508.645.5044
Vacation Rentals: 508.627.6772

Real estate website design, development and optimization by Organic Return